Not far from the Tennessee River, Chalmers's brigade runs into Stuart (detached from Sherman's Division). With artillery support and the backing of 4th Ohio Cavalry, Stuart is ready to give a good account of himself. Both sides claw each other to ribbons. In a short, sharp and scorching firefight, the 4th Ohio scatters, and little remains of Chalmers's or Stuart's commands.
In front of the Peach Orchard, Gladden also reaches his high tide. Little is left of Prentiss's Division, but what there is repulses Gladden's attack in short order. To Gladden's left, matters are also going awry for the Confederacy. Williams's of Hurlbut's Division throws back Shaver's brigade (obscured by trees) with heavy loss...
... then turns upon Gladden's depleted command. However, the latter gives as good as it takes, and still holds the line awaiting the arrival of reserves from Bragg or Polk.
Meanwhile, on the other flank, S.A.M. Wood's brigade, led by General Hardee himself, runs into Hare's brigade, with Major-Genl McClernand directing the defence in person. Together with the support of his own and Sherman's artillery, and Hildebrand's brigade as well, the Union line brings Wood's headlong advance to a sudden halt.

The general situation now shows the Confederates have been brought to a halt a little north of Shiloh Church and at the Peach Orchard. Two of Hardee's brigades have been worn down, as have a couple of Withers's brigades. The Union lines have now consolidated, but W.H.L. Wallace's 2nd Division has yet to be committed.
Fresh Confederate brigades arrive to relieve the depleted first line. Gibson and Anderson attack Hare's brigade, whilst, to their right, Stephens collides with Hildebrand (Sherman) and Jackson stops Williams (Hurlbut). Now all of Bragg's Divisions have been committed to battle.

Bushrod Johnson, of Cheatham's Division (Polk's Corps) takes over from Gladden the battle around the Peach Orchard. But the fight will be the tougher as Lauman's brigade (Hurlbut) has established a line within and around the Orchard, whilst Prentiss still holds a line to their left. Sidney Johnston's army will have more tough work ahead...
Marching up beside Oak Creek, Hardee's last brigade in action, is supported by Pond's brigade of Bragg's Corps. Some distance ahead, Sweeny's brigade of Wallace's Division awaits them. Beside them, Tuttle awaits the outcome of the firefight McClernand is having with Anderson and Gibson. Hildebrand faces superior numbers of Stephens's brigade, and, near the crossroads, a deadly duel is developing between Williams and Jackson.
Savage fighting erupts just north of Shiloh Church. The Union line takes a terrible mauling, but the Confederates are themselves taking considerable hurt. Gibson's brigade in particular takes heavy losses from Hare's brigade - all that is left of McClernand's Division.
The Confederates enjoy more success nearer the right. B.R. Johnson inflicts heavy losses upon Lauman in the Peach Orchard, and Gladden is still there, trading long bowls with Veatch's brigade, to the right rear of the Orchard.
The action is now general, all along the line. Although several brigades have been worn down, the Confederates still have several in reserve, including Breckinridge's entire command. Meanwhile, the Union still has W.H.L. Wallace's Division as yet uncommitted. Of major concern to Major-Genl Ulysses S. Grant: what is happening with the other Wallace, Lew? Surely he will be marching to the guns. But... when, if ever, will he arrive? Could he come up betimes, to reverse the tide of battle?
Approaching the crossroads, Jackson seems to have caught a Tartar, locked in a firefight with one of Hurlbut's brigades. Directing the action, Maj.Genl Withers falls, fatally wounded. Behind Jackson, Brig.Genl A.P. Stewart, together with Cheatham's artillery, awaits his turn for battle.

Cheatham himself directs the fight around the Peach Orchard. Despite heavy losses, Prentiss and Lauman refuse to budge.
for some reason straying into Cleburne's brigade, just then running into part of W.H.L. Wallace's Division, Brig.Gen Dan Ruggles receives a fatal blast of canister from Sweeny's guns.
Much of Hardee's and Bragg's Corps having been seen off by stubborn Union resistance, elements of Polk's Corps, Russell and Stephens, enter the action. The blue lines to their front look woefully thin...
By this time, Breckinridge's command is getting close to the action. His leading brigade, Bowen's, strikes what little remains of Stuart after his earlier duel with Chalmers. Owing to nearby events. Prentiss has drawn his line back into Stuart's right rear.
Fresh Confederate brigades renews the battle as the Union line once again begins to buckle. Bushrod Johnson pushes Lauman out of the Peach Orchard position, forcing Prentiss also to fall back. Jackson and A.P Stewart begin herding Veatch and William's depleted command away from the crossroads.

Bowen immediately brushes aside Stuart. Prentiss offers Stuart some artillery support, but without effect.
Pushing through the Peach Orchard B.R. Johnson shatters Lauman's command. Little remains to flee northward. But, immediately to the west, Veatch hands out an equally decisive drubbing to Jackson's brigade.

Misfortune visits the Union on the Western flank. McClernand is finally driven from the field. The brigades of Sweeny and Tuttle also get the worse of their encounter with Cleburne and Anderson.


As the afternoon wore on, the lines of both sides were looking very threadbare. The Confederates were still pushing forward against defences that were crumbling, but, apart from two of Breckinridge's brigades, and a couple more near Owl Creek, few were the reserves available to push replenish spent formations. For their part, the Union army was in even worse state. Almost nothing was left of Sherman and Prentiss; and very little of McClernand. Hurlbut was still in the fight - even doing well - but was facing lengthening odds.
... And Lew Wallace was still on the road, somewhere between Pittsburgh Landing and Stoney Lonesome...
To be concluded...




















What an epic post! I'm not sure how you remember all that action Ion
ReplyDeletePictures. Maudlin Jack: pictures. Lots of 'em. I also labelled one of the early morning pics, and used some distinguishing feature to identify brigades. Mind you I do occasionally wonder how certain formations fetch up where they do (A.P. Stewart in particular), but there they be... How Dan Ruggles strayed into the Cleburne's line is also a mystery - he ought to have been with Anderson, or back with Pond- one of his own brigades.
DeleteRunning through it now, after well over a month since it was played out, the excitement for me remains undiminished. It is all set for a climactic finish.
Cheers,
Ion
Very exciting clash, Ion! The battle seems to still hang in the balance, but both armies have really taken a pounding. Good stuff!
ReplyDeleteJonathan -
DeleteAlthough their advance has been fairly steady overall, the Confederacy has incurred checks here and there along the line, and a steady stream of losses. I'll probably do a 'debrief', outlining some of the special conventions I used for this action.
Cheers,
Ion
Still in the balance, could see it going either way, Great looking game and a cracking report, really enjoying following it's progress.
ReplyDeleteDonnie -
DeleteThanks! I had hoped to get cracking on the conclusion today, but got overtaken by other stuff. Must try harder!
Cheers,
Ion
What an excellent narrative which certainly expresses the chaos and uncertainty of the original battle. Nice idea having an ironclad turn up! I must borrow that idea. While the ACW habit of referring to units by their commanders names adds lots of flavour, it can be incredibly confusing, so your solution of italicising the Confederates works very well. I shall borrow that for my own accounts.
ReplyDeleteMartin -
DeleteI nicked the italicised Confederate names from 'National Geographic'. An alternative would be to print Union names in blue.
I think to capture the flavour of the ACW one really has to use formation commanders' names. Although the Union developed a formal Brigade/Division/Corps numbering system, the tidy effect of this convention didn't really last long. Shiloh happened before the Union adopted an Army Corps organisation, and so Grant's army comprised 6 'independent' Divisions, 1-6 being McClernand, WHL Wallace, Lew Wallace, Hurlbut, Sherman and Prentiss. But it's more fun - and more engaging, I think - to use the commanders' names. I think American readers familiar with the history of that war will understand what I mean.
You might recall that, apart from Army and wing commanders, I used formation numbers rather than names in my Hundred Days map game.
Cheers,
Ion
Archduke Piccolo,
ReplyDeleteI’d never really looked at the events of the Battle of Shiloh before … but reading your battle reports has changed that! Thank you for an excellent blog post!
All the best,
Bob
Cheers, Bob
DeleteShiloh (a.k.a. Pittsburgh Landing) is quite an interesting battle - and might have been a Confederate victory had Lew Wallace's Division had been even more tardy in its approach march, and Buell's Army of the Ohio not been in the offing.
The historical course of events were different. In this 'Portable' version, there was no 'hornet's nest' or 'horseshoe' position; and I left off the creeks that criss-cross the battlefield and Water Oaks Pond as on the whole fairly insignificant - certainly 'beneath the grain' of my game board. The place was wooded enough for cleared fields to become features rather than discrete tracts of woodland. That tended to keep ranges short.
Otherwise, events so far have, very broadly speaking, gone 'per spec'. We'll have to wait until the concluding narrative to discover how it ended...
Regards,
Ion