Monday, February 5, 2024

Portable Montereau, February 1814 (3)

 


Turn Six (and Seven): The Allies seize the initiative:
In doing so, they repulse Marshal Victor's assaults upon Surville and St Martin once and for all. Very little remains of the Line Divisions, or of the Paris Reserve. Now, were Victor alne in this fight, his corps would have routed long ago - and many rule sets would have prescribed precisely that.  In my view, although such a rule in fine for the overall army command, it is 'double jeopardy' for the army's constituent formations.  Victor has just 6 Strength Points remaining.  Very well: what has happened to the other 12? There is your rout. Apart from killed, wounded and captured, thousands of stragglers are milling about the battlefield. A tiny group of brave men remain with the colours, and remain in the fight. That the other formations are still taking it to the enemy is also keeping Victor's command in being.

Well, that's my rationale, anyhow. 

But fortunes elsewhere on the battlefield are at best mixed. Kirsch's Austrians and the Wurttemberg Light Infantry are pushing Milhaud's tired cavalry back towards Luat, but a cavalry battle raging close by Surville is holding up the river crossing by Bianchi's Corps.

What happened to the Bavarian breakout? Somehow their fate escaped the attention of the battlefield artist. Although driving off Pajol's hussars, they drew the attention of the powerful brigades of the National Guard. Heavily outmatched, the Bavarians did not long survive the encounter. The victorious National Guard continued marching on towards Villerton.



In the meantime, the long column of Bianchi's I Corps remained held up along the road, unable to move until the Surville garrison clear the streets of the town.

The dragoons reinforcing Pajol's chasseurs, the long drawn out running battle with Walsleben's cavalry came to a sudden end with the latter's collapse. Suddenly Kirsch's artillery line was threatened from a flank... 

... and it was now that the portentous dark cloud began to blanket the fields to the north: the Emperor napoleon, and the Imperial Guard. Exelmans's light horse and Delort's heavies, led by Nansouty (wearing a chasseur uniform in this day), advanced across the fields, whilst Friant's Old guard took the road through Forges to Luat.




As Milhaud and victor pull back from St Martin towards Luat, Schafer and Doring's brigades follow up. By so doing they clear the road for Bianchi's delayed troops to cross the river into Surville. 
 



Led by General Koch himself, Austrians and Wurttembergers drive the formed remnants of Duhesme's Division upon the equally depleted Paris Reserve. Marshal Victor rallies what is left of his infantry in a new line.


Turn Eight: The Allies keep the initiative.
The quick-witted and observant reader will wonder what happened to Turn 7, and so do I. I think I simply forgot around this time to take enough pictures, and thereby omitted the move marker. However the previous two pictures seem sufficient to me to indicate two turns had gone by, as Koch drove back Victor's Corps well away from the riverside towns.


The streets of Surville now unencumbered, Bianchi's column begins to pour across the bridges. Then comes another hold-up. Barely emerging from the western outskirts of Surville, Raigecourt's cavalry run into Milhaud's chasseurs.  This is doubly bad news, for the chasseurs shortly before have overrun  Austrian artillery that had formed a battery line between St Martin and Villeron. Bianchi's column seems to be facing more delays.


However, Raigecourt does receive some support from some of Bianchi's artillery detached and in battery in a loop of the river, firing into the flank of Pajol's horse. On the other hand French pressure has been so determined, that the Wurttemberg advance guard infantry have now been cut off in Villeron and are under heavy assault from Pacthod's National Guardsmen.

All this while, the Imperial Guard continues to pour into the battlefield.  The leading elements of the Old Guard are marching through Luat, where they are greeted by Milhaud's dragoons.  The Guard cavalry remain north of the Luat-Piat Buisson road.

However depleted Victor's command, supported by Milhaud's horse artillery, continue to stand against the Allied counter-attacks. The artillery repulse a brigade sized Austrian attack, and drive the assailants back into St Martin.  


It is becoming apparent that the Imperial Guard can reinforce the French attacks far more quickly than can Bianchi the beleaguered bridgehead.  Unable to break out into the open, Raigecourt's cavalry are clogging the streets of Surville.  It is only the stout resistance of the green-coats in Villeron that has delayed Pacthod's advance upon the riverside town.


The situation indicating that there was no real prospect now of expanding the bridgehead, let alone saving the garrison of Villeron, Prince Eugene of Wurttemberg sounds the retreat. Darkness drawing in upon a late winter afternoon, the Allies are able, less the Villeron garrison, to pull back across the river overnight. With no escape, Stockmeyer's Wurttemberg advance guard surrender themselves after dark. Otherwise, there was no pursuit.

Undoubted French victory though reported in the Bulletin, there was no question that the Grand Armee had received a severe knock. Marshal Victor's Army Corps had lost over half the total French losses, and they fell just barely short of the Army's exhaustion point. For their part, the Allies had lost just 26SP not counting a divisional commander (Walsleben) and also not counting what remained to surrender of Stockmeyer's light infantry. 

 


8 comments:

  1. What an enjoyable account! Your PW mashup rules seem to have worked well too. I really must look at PW Napoleonic again, but every time I try them I'm disappointed, and the prospect of having to re write them from the ground up to produce a game I like is a bit daunting.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Martin -
      Thanks for you comment. I sometimes wonder what it is I like about the PW concept: it certainly drew me in to grid war games, which were not my thing at all until about 6 years ago. I simply adapted them to my own set-up.

      Thinking back over this particular action, though, I wonder whether you would have been persuaded to a different view from that you current hold. Quite a few of the events were a little strange - Victor's repulse, the long running cavalry fight which traversed 5(!) hexes, and Wurttemberg's difficulty in keeping his forces under control, having to dice for nearly all of them. It was a long time before the Bavarians got going!

      But I have long been thinking about reviving the rule set I devised for the 'Vales of Lyndhurst' Chronicles (see https://archdukepiccolo.blogspot.com/2018/10/vales-of-lyndhurst-to-be-continued.html )
      They were deliberately a 'one brain cell' set, but gave what I considered to be a very satisfactory game. If you do check this out, you might want to continue on through to the 'Combat at Aldbury', where I settle on 8-figure infantry and 6-figure cavalry units/formations.

      However, I might reserve the rule set for circa Marlburian. Something to think about, anyhow.
      Cheers,
      Ion

      Delete
  2. Archduke Piccolo,

    I’ve really enjoyed reading your series on Napoleonic battle reports and they’ve convinced me not to get rid of my collection prior to our house move. More glory awaits them in the future!

    All the best,

    Bob

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Bob -
      I'm glad to see that you'll be keeping your Napoleonic collection. I seem to recall your development of army-level organisations - somewhere between Thistlebarrow's and my own, as I recall. I would be nice to see it in action whether PW or 'free board'.

      But I am glad to put this project away for a while, and look at other plans, plots and schemes. Your recent mention of the Hyderabad thing has suggested to me a little potted campaign, or possibly a map game, very loosely based on the absorption of that State into 'Greater India'. I think, though, I will give ... Loderabad? Hyderanasti? ... a regular army of sorts, and the interior lines, of course - just to make a fight of it...
      Cheers,
      Ion

      Delete
  3. A fitting conclusion to a hard fought battle, with the Emperors arrival turning the tide, although the guard didn't do much. No doubt the bulletin will claim a great victory....

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mark -
      You've reminded me of something I forgot to mention to Martin as one of the strange features of that battle as gamed: the roles of the reinforcing corps on both sides. They were little more than walk-on parts. Bianchi's advance guard and some of his artillery saw action. Mostly the corps was held up for too long on account of the bottleneck at Surville.

      None of the Imperial Guard saw action at all. I started dice rolling for arrival at move 5, I think, but really Pajol, Milhaud and Victor ought to have been enough to eliminate the bridgehead, especially as they (would have) had their respective commands under better control (i.e. less scattered about).

      On the whole, this ought to have been a pretty one-sided action, as it was historically, but those Austrians and Wurttembergers fought like demons!
      Cheers,
      Ion

      Delete
  4. Oh well… so the French won this time ☹️
    Historically we English will have to console ourselves that things eventually “turn out right” at the end and that the little Corsican fella gets his comeuppance.
    Cheers,
    Geoff

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Geoff -
      Had the historical battle gone the way this one went, Napoleon would have regretted the fact. The French got a very bloody nose. Historically the French lost 2580 men, the Allies 6500, almost half of them POW.

      You probably know by now that I rather like the 'little Corsican fella' - the world could use some people like him right about now. But it is true that my recent Napoleonic battles have been, by and large, going his way. That may well change. We will be looking at some 1810-11 Peninsular War action soon.
      Cheers,
      Ion

      Delete